Like a cliché, some songs lose their original meaning if listened to
over and over again. It's the good songs, the artful ones, though,
that retain their meaning. Yes, I experience song-burnout, but with
the good songs, it's always there, when I'm ready for it again.
My favorite songs tell a story through their lyrics, vocals, and instrumentals. My favorite songs grow with me. While I'm still young, I'm
reaching the age where songs begin to evolve in meaning, depending on
the time and space. Take the ex who introduced you to Junior Boys and
LCD Soundsystem. Take the middle school friends who convinced you to
play guitar and Sublime. The songs meant wildly different things now
and then, and I love them all the same, wildly.
I had a recent fling with Joni Mitchell's Blue. I had listened
to Joni Mitchell before but in the peripheral sense: I had heard that
song before; this song sounded familiar; etc.. Now that I'm older,
with a wearing-out pair of ears, I gave Mitchell a good, thoughtful
listen. I didn't think too hard, though. I listened and let her tell
her story.
Blue was written after Mitchell's
difficult break-up with Graham Nash, some while traveling Europe. The
themes of heart break, the sadness that follows, and the road and
redemption ahead are not unique. Many artists fail to compose work
that covers these topics in a digestible form that won't make you vomit.
But her work is so damn lyrically, vocally, and instrumentally
insightful that she avoids the “bad” sentimentalism, and she
transports us to her emotionally lush oracular-world.
In “A Case of You,” she masterfully
depicts her infatuation, addiction to her past love.
Oh you are in my blood like holy wine/
Oh and you taste so bitter but you
taste so sweet/
Oh I could drink a case of you/
I could drink a case of you darling/
And I would still be on my feet/
Oh I'd still be on my feet.
While the entire album is filled with
gems, it's “California” that gets me. “California” takes us
through her journey, where she runs away, literally moving
on. After she's run enough, exhausting her alienation, she knows it's
time to come back home, to California. The return is when she can
really move on. So as she is ready to go home, she asks California to
take her as she is. And this is the end of the song, the most
important part of the song. We don't need to hear the resolution
because we know that when you come face-to-face with your emotions, you're going somewhere; California, like Joni's feelings, like Joni's
close family and friends aren't going anywhere. Thank you, Joni. I look forward to listening to this song again tomorrow, the day after, and when I'm really old.
Excellent, A.L.
ReplyDeleteLooks like I have a bit to catch-up on.
Dave, thanks! Feedback like yours motivates me to continue this writing experiment.
ReplyDeleteI love this, beautiful. One day, it'll serve as a time capsule written about time capsules. How meta :)
ReplyDelete-glo